Skip to main content
Taqueria Y Tortilleria El Benny
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Catering
  • Contact
Order Now
Home Menu Catering Contact Order Now

Tortillas Recién Hechas

El Benny — Menú

100% De Maiz

Monday – Saturday 11AM – 9PM
Sunday 9AM – 7PM
Tacos Combos Burritos Tortas Especialidades Fin de Semana Aperitivos Postres Bebidas Sides Niños

Tacos

Tacos on handmade corn tortillas Tacos

A single, authentic street-style taco served on a warm 100% corn tortilla made fresh in-house daily. Topped with your choice of protein, fresh diced onions and chopped cilantro, with a lime wedge and house salsa.

Asada · Pollo · Al Pastor · Chorizo · Carnitas · Carne Molida · Birria · Pierna · Pescado · Vegetariano $4
Lengua · Tripa · Camarón $5

Combos

Tacos
2 tacos per order · Includes rice, refried beans & a soft drink
$12.99
Chilaquiles
Includes a soft drink
$12.99
Enchiladas
2 per order · Includes rice, refried beans & a soft drink
$12.99
Flautas
2 per order · Includes rice, refried beans & a soft drink
$12.99
Sopes
2 per order · Includes rice, refried beans & a soft drink
$12.99
Tamales
2 per order · Includes rice, refried beans & a soft drink
$12.99
Burrito
Lettuce, cheese & sour cream · Includes rice, refried beans & a soft drink
$12.99

Burritos & Quesadillas

Quesadilla

All burritos come with lettuce, sour cream, beans and rice, with your choice of meat. Quesadillas are melted cheese in a folded tortilla, served with refried beans, Mexican rice and a side of lettuce, tomato and sour cream.

Burrito / Quesadilla
Birria · Asada · Al Pastor · Chorizo · Carnitas · Pollo · Carne Molida
$12.99

Tortas

Torta

All tortas come with lettuce, mayonnaise, cheese, beans and avocado, with your choice of meat.

Torta
A massive, authentic Mexican sandwich served on a traditional bolillo roll, toasted to a perfect golden crisp. Asada · Al Pastor · Chorizo · Carnitas · Milanesa · Pollo
$12
Torta Cubana
$15

Especialidades / Specialties

Hearty, complete dinner platters featuring slow-simmered meats and scratch-made sauces — every platter served with seasoned Mexican rice, savory refried beans, and a warm stack of our signature corn tortillas made fresh in-house daily.

Quesa Birrias
Quesa Birrias $14.99 Juicy, slow-cooked birria beef and melted cheese stuffed inside a quesadilla crisped in savory red chile broth, served with consommé for dipping.
Carne Asada
Carne Asada $20.99 Tender, perfectly grilled skirt steak served with charred green jalapeños and grilled onions.
Mojarra Frita
Mojarra Frita $18.99 Whole fried tilapia garnished with fresh lime and served with a side of sliced onions, tomatoes and rice.
Camarones a la Diabla
Camarones a la Diabla $17.99 Plump, juicy shrimp tossed with sautéed onions in a fiery, rich red diabla sauce.
Lengua en Salsa Verde
Lengua en Salsa Verde $17.99 Tender beef tongue simmered in green salsa, served with refried beans topped with cheese and seasoned Mexican rice.
Bistec a la Mexicana
Bistec a la Mexicana $15.99 Juicy, tender strips of steak sautéed with fresh jalapeños, onions, and ripe tomatoes for an authentic kick.
Pollo a la Plancha
Pollo a la Plancha $15.99 Grilled chicken breast with sautéed bell peppers, zucchini, broccoli, and tomatoes, served alongside refried beans topped with cheese.
Flautas
Flautas $15 Two extra-long corn tortillas tightly rolled with your choice of savory shredded chicken or tender shredded beef, fried to a golden crisp.
Arroz con Pollo
Arroz con Pollo $12 Tender, seasoned grilled chicken bites layered over a bed of savory Mexican rice.
Tortillas recién hechas
Tortillas $2.75 One pound of our signature corn tortillas, handcrafted from scratch and made fresh in-house daily. Served warm and ready to enjoy.
Carnitas $15.99

Especiales de Fin de Semana

Weekend Specials — comforting, traditional Mexican caldos and stews slow-cooked to perfection. Rich, flavorful broths packed with fresh ingredients and served with classic toppings.

Birria
Birria $15.99 A rich, deeply flavorful traditional Mexican stew featuring tender, slow-simmered beef in a savory consommé.
Pozole
Pozole $15.99 A deeply comforting, traditional Mexican soup featuring tender, juicy chunks of pork and soft hominy corn kernels.
Caldo de Res
Caldo de Res $15.99 A comforting, hearty Mexican beef soup packed with tender chunks of beef and fresh vegetables, including sweet corn on the cob and carrots.
Menudo
Tender, thoroughly cleaned beef tripe slow-simmered in a deeply savory, red guajillo chile broth. Served with crushed oregano, red pepper flakes and fresh lime.
$15.99
Caldo de Camaron
A robust, flavorful wild-caught shrimp soup simmered in a seasoned tomato and dried chile broth, packed with tender potatoes, carrots and celery.
$18.99

Aperitivos / Appetizers

Chips and queso
Totopos y Salsa
A generous portion of our signature corn tortilla chips — cut and fried in-house daily for the ultimate satisfying crunch.
$1.75
Guacamole
Made fresh throughout the day using 100% ripe avocados, gently hand-crushed for the perfect creamy yet chunky texture.
$7
Queso Dip
Crisp, golden tortilla chips served alongside our signature warm, velvety smooth white queso dip.
$7
Chorizo Dip
Our signature rich and velvety white queso dip, served piping hot and loaded with flavorful, spiced house-made Mexican chorizo.
$7.50

Postres / Desserts

Churros
Churros
Fried dough sticks rolled in cinnamon and sugar, typically served with chocolate syrup and whipped cream.
$4.75
Flan
Mexican custard made with eggs, milk and sugar, featuring a smooth texture and caramel sauce.
$4.75
Cheese Cake $4.75
Arroz con Leche
Rice pudding simmered in milk, sugar and cinnamon, often enriched with raisins or vanilla for a classic Mexican dessert.
$4.75

Bebidas / Drinks

Horchata $4
Jamaica $4
Refrescos de Botella $4
Refresco $3
Café $3

Adicionales / Sides

Aguacate $4.50
Papas Fritas $4.99
Frijoles Refritos $3.99
Arroz $3.99
Crema Agria $3.99
Chiles Toreados $2.50
Jalapeños $2.50
Queso Rallado $2.50
Tortillas (3) $2.50

Menu Infantil / Children's Menu

Chicken Nuggets $8.99
Burrito $8.99
Enchilada $8.99
Taco $8.99
Refresco $3
Home Catering Contact
El Benny 8975 E Washington St, Ste 102, Indianapolis, IN 46219  ·  (463) 224-7101